The strategy
Whatever the reason, Neil's strategy is obvious: siege lawfare. He'll sit on historic properties and leave them abandoned or neglected until they fall into disrepair. Meanwhile, his lawyers attempt to overwhelm the city's legal team with floods of frivolous lawsuits and FOIA requests. Once the city's legal resources are drained and the property values have tanked, it'll be game over.
The corporate structure tells the story. Bender and his firm operate through at least eight separate LLCs for what are essentially contiguous properties in Uptown Kingston. That's not normal. These LLCs are essentially litigation architecture designed for more complexity, more legal surface area, and more burden on the city to respond.
The Pike Plan, right now
Neil Bender and his firm have filed seven lawsuits to halt or disrupt the city's Pike Plan. They claim to be invested in "the preservation and restoration of historic properties." But the crumbling Pike Plan canopies they're so passionately defending were installed in the 1970s.
In fact, the New York State Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation called the Pike Plan a "non-contributing or non-historic" feature of the National Register-listed Stockade Historic District and recommended demolishing the Pike Plan in order to restore the historic storefronts.
Preservation of history is a noble pursuit.
Neil Bender just wants to own it.

